67 Comments
founding

Oh, man, I feel so conflicted about this one.

When I talk with friends about money I distinguish between big-picture mentality and goals and day-to-day practice. I am totally on the same page as Dana about those big-picture goals of paying off all your debt, getting as rich as possible, etc. I’m particularly skeptical of FIRE - it reminds me of those sects of Christianity that preach abstinence before marriage and then also set the expectation that sex within marriage should be this enticing hedonistic wonderland. Like, no.

But. Budgeting as a day-to-day practice changed my life.

For years I told myself my problem was that I didn’t have enough money, and I’m sure there were times that was true. But then I got a contract where my income went up 40%. I was definitely making Enough Money and I still felt the same at the end of every month. So I started educating myself, tried a few budget apps, got a handle on what I was spending. And then when my contract ended and my income went down 20%? I‘d never felt so in control of my money. All my bills got paid, I could treat myself and have some fun, and I didn’t feel that desperation at the end of each month.

The founder of YNAB once compared a good budget to a good butler - sometimes the butler asks “are you quite certain?” and other times the butler says “very good madam, I’ll make it happen right away.” This sounds and feels right to me. For me, figuring out budgeting in my day-to-day has been like learning to be my own excellent butler.

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2022Liked by Virginia Sole-Smith

This episode was good food-for-thought, and I appreciate the further conversation in the comments. I see the parallels/overlap between diet culture and budget culture, and I think it’s important to interrogate the narratives we are fed around finances and who they are coming from. When my husband and I got married, we decided that “wealth is not a value for this family” in an attempt to guide our financial approach. I think it can be freeing to reject the pressure to build net worth, “level up,” get the mansion, etc. that we often see reflected online. However, I think similar critiques can be made of “conscious spending” that can be made of intuitive eating. One being the amount of privilege involved in giving up budgeting. For example, I don’t grocery shop with a budget. We have no limits as a family on what we can spend on food. This is a result of not needing to worry if the bill is higher on a particular week. It also allows me to cultivate peace with food as we shop with a list and then allow a “shop with your heart” section where we pick up anything extra that is sounding good that week (a new item at TJ’s, a type of chip we’re craving, etc.). But I know that approaching grocery shopping this way is due to our financial privilege. When I had less money a few years ago, I handled shopping completely differently and I would not have been comfortable going without a budget when I didn’t have the flexibility to spend an extra $20 that week.

And with inflation, we have been looking at places we can scale back since our rent has increased, laundry fees have increased, food costs have gone up, etc. We’ve asked things like “do we need subscriptions to all these streaming services or can we cancel some? Do we need to eat out at this restaurant or can we find somewhere cheaper? Do I need this higher end shampoo or can I find an option at Kroger?” I want to acknowledge that none of these are very big sacrifices (we’re still eating out) but there is an element of restriction in limiting where we can eat, what shows/movies are available to us, etc. And I’m not sure that it’s totally a bad thing. It’s definitely a conversation around what our values and goals are and what is winning out at any particular moment. All this to say I think the parallel breaks down for me at a certain point.

But this isn’t my final opinion (I’m even nervous posting a response I’ve only started thinking about today), and I’ll definitely be reflecting further.

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2022Liked by Virginia Sole-Smith

I'm very conflicted by this because while I can in general understand how fighting against mindsets of extreme restriction (and interrogating capitalist values) is a worthwhile goal, I'm a disabled person who receives government 'benefits" and find the perspective put forth in this interview to be very limited/privileged. I suppose it's easy to think about budgeting as too inherently restrictive if it's a matter of, say, paying down your mortgage aggressively versus taking a nice family vacation - but if the consequences are "I will not be able to afford medical care I need to function" or "I will not be able to afford food or a place to live" budgeting can very literally be a survival tool. That's not even counting the ways in which many disabled people are quite literally forced into performing "financial responsibility" in order to prove to others that they deserve the basic right to live independently with control over their own money at all.

I should take a moment here to point out that I am *incredibly* privileged as far as these things go with disabled people in America and I still wake up every day feeling this precarity and wondering if any little indulgence is going to mean that I might not be able to afford care I need, leading me with lasting irreparable physical damage (which has happened before.) And this is with things like a supportive working partner, a house, a car, etc! It's an odd balance to strike mentally between knowing that so much of the need for budgeting is caused by external systems that require changing (would feel a lot better buying some nice yarn once in a while if I knew we had universal healthcare) and also that at the end of the day it's a survival tool.

I'm looking forward to reading the comments as they come in, since this topic is very thought provoking and bound to bring up some good perspectives!

Expand full comment
founding
Aug 18, 2022Liked by Virginia Sole-Smith

This was a really interesting convo (as always!) but I am left with some conflicting feelings around it. Compared to dieting, where I have increasingly seen SO many people have the exact same experience, the opposite is true with money and finance. One thing that immediately struck me was this idea that budgeting is all about "being rich", which is something I have never associated with budgeting or necessarily felt like I have been sold as a part of it. It almost feels to me like the idea of casting off the restriction of "budgeting" is a privileged idea in itself? I grew up in what I guess was the lower working class. We never had food insecurity and had clothes and shelter, but never had anything extra and my parents were always in debt and fighting about money. So for me, taking back some control and understanding of money now that I'm in a very different income bracket has felt really empowering. It has taught me that it is important to see where your money is going, and it gives me the choice of how I spend it now that I finally have that extra that I never had. I was never given any information about money or tools for understanding how to manage it. In dieting, women have been pushed towards focusing on something that we now realize is trivial. Finance to me has always been seen as something left to the (white) men with women actively excluded in the past, despite it being far more vital to our lives. I am really having trouble with the idea that women and other marginalized groups should disengage with budget culture the same way we have with diet culture. The language of restriction and the false marketing around budgeting is a totally fair thing to reject, but it feels like we could be throwing the baby out with the bathwater. Changing the way we talk about money, more open discussion, re-framing ideas around debt and spending, these are all great things. Maybe the way budgeting has been sold to a certain group/class specifically needs to be changed, but I don't think it is accurate or fair to compare it to dieting. Women especially have been steeped in diet culture for at least the last hundred years — talking about money and budgets has been a closed door for many women until very recently. Even if, like dieting, there are some pretty frustrating aspects of how we talk about budgeting, it feels like a more convenient comparison than it is a totally true one. Food for thought I guess. Thank you so much for doing this work!

Expand full comment

I found a lot of this conversation troubling and very bad advice. For one, the blithe universal assertion that "budgets don't work" with zero evidence beyond the personal and emotional. In fact, in the very next sentence, Dana mentions that there isn't much research into the efficacy of budgets. So where does this claim come from? What supports it, beyond her personal feelings that budgets are bad? There were a lot of personal experiences and reflections phrased as universals throughout the conversation: we feel this, we do that, we have this result (I find Anne Helen Peterson writes in a similar way). Who's the "we" in those statements? Where's the evidence to support that this is how--a majority of Americans? The bulk of Virginia's audience? "Ordinary" people? I'm not sure who "we" encompasses--think, feel, and behave? The dismissal of YNAB as x, y, z while admitting that she hasn't used it (and then mischaracterizing the way it works--you set your goals, categories, and amounts, you move money between categories as you see fit, expenses are tallied seamlessly and easily, and the tone is consistently non-judgmental and encouraging).

And then "conscious spending" advocated as the alternative...which is like a fuzzier, less accurate form of expense tracking.

The idea of dispensing with retirement planning is also deeply concerning advice.

People with perfectionist tendencies will find comfort and security in tracking and controlling aspects of their lives. This isn't inherently bad. And if you've got an anxiety disorder triggered by tracking your money, I suggest addressing this problem with a qualified therapist rather than deciding that its not worth keeping track of your money any more (speaking from experience here!) or planning for future unemployment or retirement (or your children's needs and educations).

Of course there's plenty of toxic bro posturing in the personal finance space. But there are also a lot of people who thoughtfully consider the same issues Dana argues are ignored--what it means to be "rich," how to set and achieve short- and long-term goals, how to determine when the challenges with achieving those goals is the goal, is your spending, or is your income, and how to plan solutions to those problems.

This conversation left me really concerned and unsettled and disappointed that Virginia didn't interrogate more of these claims with the same clear-eyed objectivity she has when she approaches aspects of medical reporting.

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2022Liked by Virginia Sole-Smith

Thank you Dana for this thoughtful conversation! I completely agree with so many of your ideas. I struggled mightily for most of my life as the person in all the families I was in who earned the money kept track of money did the taxes blah blah blah. It was hell and exactly like an eating disorder.

Then I got ill and became disabled.

The money thing became truly terrifying, and I found YNAB. In our more broke and lower income status making us more “regular” YNAB has set me free. It keeps track. I don’t worry. As time has gone by… It’s been six years… I freely move money from any category to cover the haircolor I needed for morale without a second thought. We recently just dumped every single penny we had in savings to pay off our mortgage, and are struggling to have any savings at all, and it’s totally OK.

But maybe it’s like financial Al-Anon for people with money issues and if that’s the case. I’m really thankful for it. Now my husband can see the finances and my kids can see them and I get to share the load.

That said, I recognize everyone doesn’t need AA, and therefore everyone doesn’t need YNAB. But some do and it’s good to have support.

Expand full comment
founding
Aug 19, 2022Liked by Virginia Sole-Smith

I previously worked in “financial literacy” and have now come to understand that you can give someone all the tools in the world but if they don’t have the income to cover basic needs then that’s the issue. I appreciate that this point was made but I wish the conversation had dug deeper on those inequities. I also think that instead of “good” vs “bad” debt, you could think of it as “predatory” vs “asset building”. So many people are only given access to predatory types of lending that are designed to keep them in a constant loop of debt just to cover basic costs. While people with money can access lending to purchase assets like a home or education that will provide for a more stable future. And finally, taking away pensions to put the onus on individuals to save for retirement via 401ks was just incredibly unethical. It’s an absolute crapshoot to plan for retirement this way. All in all, I think we all could have a healthier relationship with money but the more important issue is to create systemic changes in our country to actually help everyone get a living wage and have access to better lending and retirement planning.

Expand full comment
Aug 19, 2022Liked by Virginia Sole-Smith

I thought I was the only one who had huge issues with this interview and I’m relieved to not be alone. I just kept thinking “money is fluid *if you have access to non-predatory credit.* You can practice “conscious spending” if you have enough cash on hand OR access to non-predatory credit! (Also, I don’t understand how being mindful of how much money I have on hand and how much is coming in/going out to other things this month isn’t “conscious spending” - and I call that “budgeting.”)

Rich people carry tons of debt because they have collateral that allows them to access huge amounts of credit with favorable terms and low interest rates. The rest of us may not have access even to things like mortgages and student loans (if we’re not students). “Bad debt” isn’t bad because the person who holds it made a bad choice, it’s bad because it hurts them and is emblematic of a system where some people can treat money like it’s fluid and others have to count every penny. This is a terrible system! But hand-waving it away as “budget culture” doesn’t change the system.

When I was in my 20s, I earned a low salary (nonprofits!) in an expensive city and had almost no access to credit (no history, so my first credit card had a $700 limit). In the wake of the financial crisis, banks had gotten skittish about lending to people like me. My then-gf also earned a low salary and had no credit history. We budgeted in a spreadsheet every month and yes, it felt like restriction but also, we liked being housed and having food to eat? And it empowered us to say to friends “hey, we can’t do dinner and drinks this weekend but we’d love to do something cheaper or free” - and we lived in a city full of awesome cheap/free things to do with friends, so it wasn’t really a hardship; just a fact of life at the time. I’m so glad we had a budget that allowed us to enjoy our 20s without getting evicted or stressing out about money all the time.

Now that we have more money coming in, we don’t budget as tightly. Does it feel good? Yep! Is it entirely a byproduct of financial privilege? You bet. It’s not “conscious spending” - it’s “having a safety cushion and higher incomes and access to low-interest borrowing when we need it.” It’s the system working for us. It’s privilege. We didn’t need to “ditch budget culture”… we just needed more money and better credit scores.

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2022Liked by Virginia Sole-Smith

Lol, I'm another YNAB devotee signing in to express some differing opinions from Dana. I also have spent the last 15+ years writing frequently about personal finance and investing - some journalism, but largely on behalf of the giant financial services companies that underpin the American (and global) economy. So, a whole continent of salt there. I find what Dana said about retirement to be terrifying -- the idea of waiting until retirement age to see how it all works out is not how I want to spend the last part of my life! I might feel differently if we had a functioning social safety net. But in its absence, I need to make sure I take care of myself, especially since I have the means to do so. (Lots of privilege here, too, obviously.)

Given the particulars of my life experience - raising a teen in ED recovery and writing a lot for financial services companies - the comparison of diet culture to budgeting feels a lot like apples and oranges to me. But I really appreciate this interview for pushing on some long-held assumptions, whether I ultimately agree with them or not.

This is a bit of an aside, but I turned 50 last month and am *really* struggling of late to figure out where I can fight the system(s), and where I need to just preserve my energy and understand that one person's actions aren't going to have much practical impact (no ethical consumption under capitalism etc etc). I'm doing a ton of grappling w/ the insidiousness of capitalism and hustle culture... and also I have to pay my mortgage and send my kid to college in two years. Sometimes it all really just makes my head hurt.

Expand full comment
Aug 19, 2022Liked by Virginia Sole-Smith

I actually really like this discussion and don't entirely disagree with the points articulated! Especially the identification of a "universally assumed goal" (to be thin; to be rich) and consideration of it for either adopting or rejecting.

I spent most of my life living well within my means and, with the "thin-budget" privilege that came with being a single person with steady employment and a healthy side-hustle, assumed that meant I was good at budgeting. My wants were fairly simple and easily satisfied by my earnings, with plenty leftover to save. Once I had my kids, upsized my living situation, took various maternity leaves for them (as a freelancer, no less), couldn't just throw all my waking hours at the wall and extract all the money possible from the market (ie had to be the primary parent to my kids and fit my work into a set period of hours), I realized that the situation before had not really been that I was just so good at managing money - it was that my wants cost less than my income, so I never had to confront the hard choices. Now, my wants feel infinite - I want my kids to take gymnastics! I want them to have snow gear. I want them to have a mom who is home for weekly movie nights! etc - and my income feels far more constrained. I have to really weigh priorities and resources (time, financial) and decide things like: what is the goal of this? does this decision serve that goal or not? etc.

For me, that all DOES mirror my relationship to my body. Just like I don't believe body positivity is just saying, "physical health doesn't exist!!" I don't believe that considering my financial goals and choices is just about throwing caution to the wind and buying everything I want. Mostly, it's about considering my (family's) mental and emotional health as well as our financial health, and critically examining what that blend of priorities triangulates for us. For me it's far more about an emotional state of compassion and understanding of my own human self, than about any concrete set of actions or choices.

Expand full comment
founding
Aug 18, 2022Liked by Virginia Sole-Smith

I use YNAB and have for years. I find it helpful because I can easily see what we’re spending on things, move money as needed WITHOUT guilt, and purposefully add money to buckets when I am seeing that we’re not being realistic. For me, who has a history of traumatic money experiences, seeing the tracking is helpful. This doesn’t feel like restriction to me because I use it in a way that works for our family and ignore all of their suggestions and emails to do it differently or in a certain way. I do feel like all budgeting advice online does feel like a diet though.

Expand full comment

I've read every comment so far and want to start by saying I love how thoughtful everyone's responses are here.

For me, having ADHD and being self-employed has made using YNAB one of the smartest financial decisions I've ever made. Being able to save enough each month for regular but less frequent expenses (car insurance, annual subscription renewals, etc.) has been so helpful to me and my particular brain. I never feel deprived because that's not what this system is about; it's about being aware and making conscious choices about where to put your money. As for the cult following thing, sometimes things are popular because they're good and they bring about life-changing positive results.

I agree with others who said that the diet/budget comparison didn't feel accurate, especially given our lack of a social safety net, the cost of elder care, the very real risk of outliving our retirement savings, and people who don't have the privilege to spend "consciously" without some sort of structure that helps them not only stay organized, but literally solvent and able to remain housed and have food.

I think this episode was a great starting point into analyzing the Venn diagram between diet culture and wealth/prosperity gospel culture--but maybe not budgeting culture, per se. Unpacking ideas about the dearth of research into whether budgeting works and how to come up with financial systems that serve everyone, not just the culturally and financially privileged, are fascinating and bear further exploration.

Expand full comment
Aug 19, 2022·edited Aug 19, 2022Liked by Virginia Sole-Smith

I found this so thought-provoking - thanks for hosting, Virginia, and I hope this discussion continues with more analysis and perspectives (including perhaps Dana's again!).

I wanted to share a couple of my own experiences. The big thing going on in my life right now is that my father-in-law passed away very unexpectedly earlier this summer. He retired only a year ago and was loving being retired. And he worked really hard for his savings - he was a mechanic. I already "knew" this but it really drives home the point that retirement isn't guaranteed. I certainly wish my husband and I had prioritized doing something fun with them every year (we live multiple flights away from them). I wish we had sprung for a real vacation with them every year now instead of paying off student loans, saving for a house. It *is* a privilege to be deciding among those choices, yes. But also yeah I wish we had been less focused on our budget and how much we "should" spend on travel each year. (Not needing sympathy - my father-in-law definitely knew we loved him and we made it out for important occasions - just reflecting on how not just actual finances but also maybe budget culture, which I hadn't really thought about as a thing I guess, had real effects you know?)

Another element I would like to read more about and am thinking about from my own experience is "who has to budget and to what degree" being a little like "who has to [try to] diet and to what degree" based on biology and social structures? Like if you have "enough" money, you don't really have to budget right?

Anyway, thanks again for the thought-provoking reading, Virginia, Dana, and other commenters! And Virginia, hope you have a great vacation!

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2022Liked by Virginia Sole-Smith

I loved this episode! I think diet culture and budget culture are great comparisons, and it really rung true for me because my mother is a huge Dave Ramsey fan and also very influenced by diet culture. She's always tried to get me to follow Dave Ramsey and I never have. I 100% agree that most white male financial "gurus" are selling nonsense that doesn't make sense for most people. I happily take on debt for a mortgage and cars - the idea that we need to pay cash for those things or pay them off ASAP is just so limiting and unecessary. And I agree that the idea of bad/good budgeting and restriction is worth discussing. It's never made sense to me that anyone who is living in poverty or in a lower income bracket can simply budget their way into having more money. Instead, we need to help them access resources and jobs that will provide a living wage. I do pause at saying budget trackers are like calorie or weight trackers. I personally use YNAB. I don't really pay attention to the advice it gives or try to follow certain rules, but having a general sense of where of my money is going, remembering to pay my bills on time, and making thoughtful decisions to move money to different places based on my goals has been helpful (although I definitely have lots of privilege as someone who makes six figures). I'm really interested in hearing more about this topic.

Expand full comment
founding
Aug 19, 2022Liked by Virginia Sole-Smith

I found this to be a really fascinating conversation, and I also appreciate how it has continued here. I started tracking all of my spending on an excel spreadsheet when I graduated college. Which has now been eight years goodness. This episode definitely has me questioning the utility of that, and I was also really drawn to the idea of mindful journaling about the money one has spent.

I do think reevaluating the restriction mindset around money feels really powerful, but I also feel so much precarity around money (and this is as a postdoc who has a full time salary and health insurance). Which definitely always cuts into any enjoyment that spending money does bring. (Specifically, the need to be prepared in the case of a medical emergency).

Expand full comment
Aug 18, 2022Liked by Virginia Sole-Smith

This completely blew my mind!!! Everything Dana said made perfect sense, yet was so opposite of how I was brought up and preached to my entire life! I am always grateful for Burnt Toast--you really get some outstanding people to interview, Virginia!

Expand full comment